ubergizmo
 Ubergizmo Mobile

Misconception: Microsoft Silverlight Competes with AIR

Story posted on: February 25, 2008



So here you have it, another misconception finally cleared. First, AIR is not a bus and according to Kevin Lynch, Adobe's CTO, Microsoft Silverlight is not a competitor to AIR either, but rather to Flash. I know the, the transition is a bit lame... but I have an excuse.... it's late!

As competition goes, interestingly, Lynch sees the Mozilla's Prism project a much more able candidate. At the cocktail hours at the Adobe event, I had a chance to drill more on Lynch's competitive landscape views.

The rest of Kevin Lynch's competitive views and his video after the jump.

1) With Silverlight, Microsoft really has Adobe's Flash team on its toes, making sure they stay on top of new features, etc. But as far as AIR is concerned, this is a totally new ballgame where Microsoft is not yet playing. That perhaps explains why the guys in Redmond are spraying some FUD around the danger of using Web apps on the desktop.

2) Mozilla's Prism project is a much closer competitor to AIR. However, Lynch quickly dismissed it pointing that Adobe is up to 2 years ahead on the Mozilla folks on the concept of running Web apps on the desktop.

3) Browsers could also be seen as competing with AIR, especially with plug-ins like Google's Gears for Firefox and Internet Explorer that lets you run web apps offline. But Lynch argues that user will be confused with the user interface, as you still will see the traditional Web buttons, toolbars, tabs, etc... in what should be a classic desktop application. Makes sense to me. And you?


  (1)


User Comments

#0, PixelSlave , le 28/02/08 12:24 PM


Correct me if I am wrong -- a web app on the desktop ... isn\'t it just a desktop app connected to the web? Yes yes, I know there must be some subtle differences, but to convince me, Adobe really needs to try harder to tell me the difference b/w the twos.



Leave a Comment

(In order to cut on SPAM, anyone can leave a comment, but only comments from Typekey users will be posted immediately. Others will have to wait for a moderator to approve the comment. Thanks for your patience. Typekey is free and it takes only one minute to register)

Please be respectful of others when participating to this thread. Insulting or self-promotional comments could be removed. Thank you.



Email a Friend
To:


Your email (no spam):


Message (optional):